So I sort of cheated and cast this on before we decided that we were going to knit something for each season. This is actually a sweater based on a sweater Xander was wearing in Season 3, Episode 20, Graduation Day (Part 1).
I was never able to find a really good picture of it online just Buffy reviewers who said:
"I'm horribly riveted by Xander's sweater, which appears to be made of two mismatched halves cobbled together in the dark by a blind, loopy grandma."
So I just sorta made it up. Oh and I made it kid-sized for my little Scoobie in training.
As you can see from the side view I think I nailed the "cobbled together" look just fine.
When we get to Season 3--keep your eye out for the real sweater!